Cristiano Ronaldo vs Mohamed Salah: Who Leaves a Bigger Legacy in the Premier League?
Cristiano Ronaldo vs Mohamed Salah has been one of the most debated comparisons in Premier League history. Both players have left an undeniable mark on English football, dominating different eras with their goal-scoring prowess and influence. Ronaldo dazzled in his Manchester United stints, while Salah has redefined consistency at Liverpool. But who truly has the bigger legacy? Let’s break down their stats, achievements, and overall impact on the Premier League.
Goals, Assists, and Appearances
Cristiano Ronaldo and Mohamed Salah have both been prolific in the Premier League, though their careers in England have unfolded in different eras and roles.
Cristiano Ronaldo: Across 236 Premier League appearances, Ronaldo has scored 103 goals and provided 37 assists. His time at Manchester United was split into two spells (2003–2009 and 2021–2022), with his peak coming in the 2007–08 season when he netted 31 league goals, winning the Golden Boot. At the time, that tally was a record for a 38-game season until Salah broke it in 2017–18. Ronaldo’s goals-per-game rate in the league stands at approximately 0.44.
Sources – the-independent.com
Mohamed Salah: With 292 Premier League appearances, Salah has netted 184 goals and registered 86 assists, significantly surpassing Ronaldo’s numbers. His goals-per-game rate of around 0.63 reflects his role as Liverpool’s primary goal threat. In his debut season for Liverpool (2017–18), Salah set a new record for the most goals in a 38-game Premier League season with 32. He has consistently ranked among the league’s top scorers and is now one of the all-time top five Premier League goal scorers. Additionally, he holds the record as the highest-scoring African player in the league’s history.
Sources – talksport.com
Analysis: While Ronaldo was initially more of a traditional winger before evolving into a goal-scoring forward, Salah has been a relentless attacking force from the start. Despite playing fewer games, Ronaldo’s impact was undeniable, particularly during his peak at United. However, Salah’s consistency, longevity, and record-breaking numbers in the Premier League give him a clear statistical edge in this category.
Sources – espn.com
Individual Awards and Honors
Both Cristiano Ronaldo and Mohamed Salah have been recognized with numerous individual accolades in the Premier League, highlighting their dominance in different eras.
Premier League Golden Boot: Ronaldo claimed the league’s top scorer award once (2007–08), while Salah has won it three times – in 2017–18 (outright), 2018–19 (tied), and 2021–22 (tied). Salah’s three Golden Boots in a four-year span underline his sustained goal-scoring excellence.
Sources – premierleague.com
PFA Players’ Player of the Year (PFA POTY): Both have won this prestigious award twice – Ronaldo in consecutive seasons (2006–07, 2007–08) and Salah in 2017–18 and 2021–22 – placing them in an elite group of multiple-time winners.
Sources – espn.com
Premier League Player of the Season: Ronaldo won this official award twice (2006–07, 2007–08), while Salah secured it in 2017–18 after his record-breaking debut season at Liverpool. In 2021–22, despite winning the PFA award, Salah lost out on this title to Kevin De Bruyne.
Sources – premierleague.com
Football Writers’ Association (FWA) Footballer of the Year: Both players have earned this recognition twice – Ronaldo in 2006–07 and 2007–08, and Salah in 2017–18 and 2021–22 – highlighting their widespread acclaim from football journalists.
Sources – espn.com
Player of the Month Awards: Ronaldo has been named Premier League Player of the Month six times, with wins spanning from his early Manchester United days to his return in 2021–22. Salah, however, holds seven POTM awards (as of early 2025), marking his consistency across multiple seasons.
Sources – premierleague.com
Other Honors: Both have multiple inclusions in the PFA Team of the Year and have won the Premier League Goal of the Month (Ronaldo once, Salah twice). Salah also claimed the Playmaker Award in 2021–22 for most assists, showcasing his all-around game.
Sources – premierleague.com
Ballon d’Or Recognition: While not a Premier League-specific award, Ronaldo’s 2008 Ballon d’Or win, fueled by his 2007–08 Premier League and Champions League performances, makes him one of the few players to claim the honor while playing in England. Salah, meanwhile, was a Ballon d’Or finalist in 2018 but has never won the award.
Analysis
Both players have won nearly every major individual honor in the Premier League. Ronaldo’s two Player of the Season awards and Ballon d’Or triumph highlight his extraordinary peak, while Salah’s dominance in Golden Boots (3 vs. Ronaldo’s 1) and his sustained presence at the top give him a strong claim to superiority in consistency. While Salah has won more monthly and seasonal awards across a longer timeframe, Ronaldo’s ability to sweep all major honors in a short period (2007–08) was equally remarkable. Ultimately, it’s a close contest – Salah holds the edge in league-specific accolades, while Ronaldo’s Ballon d’Or remains a unique achievement for a Premier League-based player.
Sources – the-independent.com
Team Achievements in the Premier League
Both Ronaldo and Salah have secured major trophies with their clubs.
Premier League Titles: Ronaldo won three (2006–07, 2007–08, 2008–09) with Manchester United, playing a key role in their dominance. Salah won one (2019–20) with Liverpool, ending their 30-year wait for the league.
Sources – premierleague.com
Champions League: Both won one UCL title—Ronaldo with United in 2007–08 (scoring in the final) and Salah with Liverpool in 2018–19 (scoring the opening goal). Salah also reached two more finals (2018, 2022).
Sources – espn.com
Domestic Cups: Ronaldo won the FA Cup (2003–04) and two League Cups (2005–06, 2008–09). Salah won the FA Cup and League Cup in 2021–22.
Sources – espn.com
Other Honors: Ronaldo and Salah won the FIFA Club World Cup with their respective clubs.
Analysis: Ronaldo won more league titles (3 vs. 1), benefiting from a dominant United team. However, Salah’s Liverpool triumph was historic. Both played pivotal roles in their teams’ successes, with Salah achieving a rare domestic cup double. In numbers, Ronaldo edges it, but Salah’s contributions were transformative for Liverpool.
Longevity and Consistency in the Premier League
Cristiano Ronaldo: Ronaldo’s Premier League career is split into two phases. His first stint (2003–2009) saw him evolve from a promising youngster into a dominant force, peaking with a 31-goal season in 2007–08. His output improved each year, culminating in back-to-back world-class campaigns before moving to Real Madrid in 2009. His second stint (2021–2022) at 36 years old was brief but impressive – he scored 18 goals in his comeback season, finishing third in the Golden Boot race. Despite a strong return, his stay was short-lived, totaling about seven Premier League seasons overall. His peak years were extraordinary, but his overall Premier League tenure was relatively short.
Sources – premierleague.com
Mohamed Salah: Salah’s Premier League journey began with a brief, unremarkable Chelsea spell, but his return with Liverpool in 2017 redefined his career. Since then, he has been a model of consistency, scoring at least 19 league goals in six straight seasons and maintaining elite performance levels well into his 30s. Unlike Ronaldo, who had a few modest early years before hitting his peak, Salah was prolific from the start at Liverpool and has never had a significant dip in output.
Sources – espn.com
Analysis: Ronaldo’s Premier League peak was phenomenal but short-lived. Salah, with eight seasons and counting, has displayed unmatched consistency, making him the more enduring force in England’s top flight.
Cultural and Historical Impact on the Premier League
Cristiano Ronaldo: Ronaldo’s influence on the Premier League extends far beyond statistics. During his first spell at Manchester United (2003–2009), he became one of the league’s first true global megastars in the social media era, elevating English football’s worldwide appeal. His flair, stepovers, and free-kick technique inspired young players across the world, making him an icon beyond just Manchester United fans. His 2008 Ballon d’Or win while playing in the Premier League was a landmark moment, reinforcing the league’s status as a home for world-class talent.
Even in his 2021 return to England, his impact was immense – his second debut broke viewership records, and his jersey sales skyrocketed. Culturally, Ronaldo turned United into a must-watch team globally, helping push the Premier League’s marketing power. Though much of his career legacy was built in Spain, his time in England cemented his place among the greatest Premier League players. His stunning goals, records, and unforgettable moments ensure his place in history, with a Hall of Fame induction likely inevitable.
Sources – en.wikipedia.org
Mohamed Salah: Salah’s impact on the Premier League is equally profound but distinct. As an Egyptian and a Muslim, his success has inspired millions, particularly in the Middle East and Africa, expanding the league’s reach even further. His presence at Liverpool has helped define an era, making him a cultural and sporting icon. His influence even extended to social change – a study found that after Salah joined Liverpool, anti-Muslim sentiment and hate crimes in Merseyside decreased, showcasing the broader impact of his positive representation.
Beyond that, he became the Premier League’s all-time top African scorer, surpassing legends like Didier Drogba. His dominance in English football, alongside his record-breaking seasons and Liverpool’s historic league title win, ensures his legacy as one of the league’s greats.
Sources – talksport.com
Historical Significance: Both Ronaldo and Salah have delivered some of the greatest individual seasons in Premier League history – Ronaldo’s 2007–08 and Salah’s 2017–18 campaigns are still widely celebrated. Ronaldo helped establish the Premier League as a home for global superstars, while Salah has set new records and expanded the league’s reach to new audiences. Both have left an undeniable mark on the league, ensuring their names will be remembered for generations.
Sources – the-independent.com
Who Has the Stronger Premier League Legacy?
After evaluating all aspects of their Premier League careers – on-field brilliance, accolades, team success, consistency, and cultural influence – Mohamed Salah edges out Cristiano Ronaldo in terms of Premier League legacy.
Why Salah Has the Edge
Salah has dedicated the prime of his career to the Premier League, becoming one of the competition’s most consistent performers. His goal and assist numbers far exceed Ronaldo’s in the league, placing him among the all-time greats. He has also won multiple Player of the Year awards and has more Golden Boots than Ronaldo, highlighting his sustained dominance.
Crucially, Salah has been the driving force behind Liverpool’s Premier League and Champions League triumphs, often being their top scorer in title-winning campaigns. His seven-plus seasons of consistency mean he has left a more enduring impact on Premier League history, setting records that future generations will chase. Beyond football, Salah has played a pivotal role in expanding the league’s popularity in the Middle East and Africa while also influencing social change in England, making his legacy uniquely profound.
Sources – premierleague.com
Ronaldo’s Case for Greatness
Ronaldo’s Premier League impact is undeniable. He was the best player in the world while at Manchester United, winning the Ballon d’Or in 2008 – an achievement Salah has yet to match. His peak in 2007–08, with 31 league goals, remains one of the greatest individual seasons ever. Ronaldo also won three Premier League titles, proving himself as a central figure in a dominant era for United.
However, while his legacy in English football is huge, much of Ronaldo’s career-defining moments occurred outside the Premier League – his best years statistically came at Real Madrid. Had he spent as many seasons in England as Salah, this debate might tilt in his favor. But considering only Premier League achievements, Ronaldo’s shorter stay limits his overall footprint in the competition’s history.
Sources – premierleague.com
Verdict
Mohamed Salah has the stronger Premier League legacy due to his longevity, record-breaking feats, and sustained excellence. While Ronaldo’s peak was dazzling, Salah’s consistency over nearly a decade, combined with his all-time records and deep cultural impact, gives him the edge.
That said, both are undisputed Premier League legends, defining their respective eras and leaving fans with unforgettable moments. This comparison ultimately weighs a shorter, explosive peak versus long-term dominance, and in terms of pure Premier League legacy, Salah’s influence is now the greater.
- Aaron Rodgers Joins Steelers in $20M Shocker - June 6, 2025
- Steelers Respond After Mason Rudolph Joins Trump on Stage - June 6, 2025
- Sarina Wiegman Close to Finalising England Squad for Euro 2025 - June 5, 2025
